Took out a cheese pie. Prices are way up since last year. But pie was very good. Thin with a nice crust on edge. Lots of gooey cheese. Sauce just right. Very good NYC style pizza.

As a Paramedic I am all over long island and the 5 boros. LaPiazza in plainview by far has one of the best slices around. The thin crust and sauce amazing. If you are in the area give them a try you will not be disappointed We are always on the run so fast service is what we need the place was packed and I was still in and out in a few minutes.

Ten-year review update: La Piazza is still excellent but now that there are more locations, there are differences between them and still room for improvement compared to sister restaurant Mama Theresa's Garden City Park. If this is your first time, the two restaurants are very similar, i.e., they have the sweetest, most balanced marinara, making any dish with them delightful (see my chicken parm photos below). But since we're longtime customers, let's talk improvements: The modern chic. It only works where the function isn't impeded. Look at this video of the dressing pourer. It goes everywhere but the salad. The square plates aren't great for the smaller tables. You keep every inch of that place packed, so why lose space on corners when the rounded dishes work so well? The serviceware is a step back from Mama T's.

Excellent slice shop and Italian restaurant in Plainview long island. Got their plain round pie well done and a buffalo chicken pie and both were excellent. Undercarriage was well done and ingredients were high quality.

LA piazza Plainview location is my favorite out of them all! I've been coming here for years & the food always tastes the same!

Best ever! You have an immediate connection with someone whenever you bond over the deliciousness of La piazza! Buffalo chicken slice is what they're known for but I'm privy to the rigatoni Fiorentina, sausage peppers and onions slice, anyyyyyy of their grilled chicken broccoli rabe Sammys - honestly you can't go wrong! Be prepared to play a fun game of Jewish geography when there. This place has been a staple for me all my life and will continue to be! Oh and ask for Toniiiii!!!

So, a few buddies of mine highly recommended "La Piazza" in Plainview. They said this place was the best. Because of that glowing recommendation, I had to check it out; but be careful what you recommend. I arrived to a huge parking he lot, so there was plenty of space to park. The outside of the building looked a bit strange, they went with an older look. But inside was another story. I barely walked in before being greeted by the staff. They were so friendly. We joked a bit before I placed my order. I was a little shocked about the price per pizza, but I was hungry so I had to eat. They charged more for credit card swipes, but this is supposed to be amazing pizza. I sat down to eat and to my surprise, none of my friends are accurate. Wait! Hear me out! The Buffalo Slice, had no buffalo flavor..so with that slice, it was bland. I quickly moved on to the Marsala slice. Again, nothing special. I had some spots that were dry. Everything said and done, I would recommend just getting a cheese slice, Instead of a specialty. I mean, I wonder if they make a good regular?

4.5 stars Pizza is great! Sicilian is one of best I've ever had. Salad pie is surprisingly outrageous. Who would think a salad pie would be amazing, but it is there. Pasta dishes are pretty good as well. My favorite is fusilli with grilled chicken and broccoli rabe . Great local pizzeria with friendly service